Oh the possiblities!

Imagine a world where you can tell someone is a republican by the way they dress?  Well, in certain sections of Jerusalem that seems to be the case. Except, of course the political discourse of choice is not republican or democratic and the difference in outfits runs between secular and Dati Lumi (religious Zionist).  The irony here is that people who dress like the biggest “hippies” at least according the US ideas of what hippies wear  are actually the most Conservative, both socially and politically. As generally expected, political differences are worked out on the covered bodies of women. (There are differences in the way Dati men dress as well, and those differences have many nuances, except the items the men wear are generally symbolic – different kind of yammakas, ritual fringes and such). However, the dress of women is not marked with any specific ritual objects; (their body is the only ritual object women can own) rather, the politics are rapped up in how covered up they are, the more layers, the more “boho” the outfit, the more extremist.  Women who wear two or three skirts layered on top of each other are more  ”frumer” than women who wear pants underneath their below-the-knee skirts.  Women who wear a skirt and shirt, with a summer dress on top,  are more frum then the women who just wear a shirt and a summer dress (the dress of course is below the knee).

I’m not really sure what to make of this.  Of course I’m leaving out the  whole wig issue, since Dati Lumi women do not wear wigs, but scarves and hats (goes along with the hippie look).  I’m fascinated by the settler wannabees and actual settlers  a.k.a “the anti-hippie” adaption of a version of hippie dress that requires many layers. Is it a desire to wear regular items found in Israeli clothing stores, but adapted for modesty? That seams like the obvious answer, but the two skirts look does not go along with that theory, since both skirts are already long and flowly, and thus modest if worn alone.

Perhaps a better answer lies  in the belief that the more clothing your wear simultaneously, the more modest you are.  If one “boho” skirt is “boho,” two boho skirts, are twice as “boho” and twice as Dati Lumi. And who can resist being more of what you are? Thus by covering their bodies in outfits reminiscent of late 1960th ”make love not war”, the women manage to flip this adage and constrain their sexuality while  advocating for war.

Advertisement

About Sotah

I am a young lawyer, a writer and a mom to a baby girl. I have three wishes: 1. Write a book, a short story, write something. My writing like my knitting projects are all unfinished. 2. Talk to God - aka have a profound revelatory spiritual experience, where I will know myself in the presence of the Divine. 3. Heal from the c-section birth of my baby - and have another baby someday, and a birth of wonder and awesomeness, a healing birth whatever corporal form it will take.
This entry was posted in modesty, zionism. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Oh the possiblities!

  1. rebecca m says:

    I think spirituality is seen as connected to:
    1)strictness of halacha
    2)being creative (the boho-ness)
    3)land of Israel

    I also sometime felt that there was an attemt to forge a new “frum look” that would be different, and more “native” than the pleated skirts and blouses that charedim wear. I couldn’t prove it, though, just a thought.

  2. alan says:

    it’s a “back to the land”/”natural living” thing. that’s the piece you’re missing. they’re right-wing because they don’t want to compromise on the land, because they get their spirituality from it. hence the hippie garb.

  3. Yahav says:

    Hi Anna
    I donn’t think that women who dress modestly (or “too modestly” as you put it) are provoking war, and I think that in general you should never judge someone by what they are wearing. I know this is almost an impossoble thing to do for most people, and I also find myself doing this every day, but you should avoid it, because you never know what kind of person is underneath all the skirts. I have come to understand in my short life that people are not at all what they seem, good and bad.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s